One Tree Hill star Sophia Bush is so naturally pretty that I couldn’t help but be disappointed with her makeup look at a recent Fashion Week party.

Her skin looks healthy and well-moisturized, but it looks like her makeup artist left all the blush and bronzer at home – there’s almost no variation in her skin tone, let alone any contouring. She’s almost completely monochrome, and it makes her look overly made-up and kind of fake.

In this case, a little extra makeup might have actually made her look like she was wearing less.